The Other Side of the Cracker
While there is little doubt manufacturers are making concerted efforts to build a better chip or cracker, there is also the seemingly counterproductive efforts — occasionally made by the same companies — to take a product which is little more than candy, add healthful ingredients (such as, antioxidants, sterols or vitamins) to "health" it up and thus broaden its appeal.
|A TAXING SITUATION
The "Prevention of Childhood Obesity Act â€" S.2894," introduced by Senator Edward Kennedy of Massachusetts, would require phasing out of "junk food snacks" from school vending machines. Additionally, grants would be proposed for schools offering options that are low in calories, fat and added sugar.
This type of law could be the tip of an iceberg of regulations and lawsuits if we don't make progress improving the nutrition level of our food offerings.
This raises the odd conundrum of snack foods becoming healthier as well as "junkier." "Corn chips are now organic and stone ground, while candy continues to invade everything from our cereal to applesauce to waffles to yogurt to puddings," notes Jill Melton, R.D., consulting nutritionist for JGM LLC, Birmingham, Ala.
Currently a small percent of the huge snacks package, fruits and vegetables are a category appearing to be making headway by increasing both in prevalence and acceptance as a snack alternative.
"We can now include the fruit and vegetable industry as part of the snack industry in the non-traditional sense, since many of their items are now purposefully being positioned as snacks," explains Elizabeth Pivonka, Ph.D., president of Produce for Better Health Foundation, Wilmington, Del. "Many fruit and vegetable industry members made great strides in providing fruit and vegetable snacks in locations where they weren't [available] before."
Pivonka points to Sunkist Growers Inc., Van Nuys, Calif., and its "smiles" line of products (grapes, orange slices, apple slices); Natures Pleasures LLC, Wolcott, N.Y., with its fresh, single-serve apple slices and pineapple push-ups; and the phenomenon of fresh-cut fruit being more available in fast-food chains, airports and similar public venues.
Wendy's fruit salads and McDonald's Waldorf salad and fruit parfaits are other successful "snack-like" examples, as are the updated traditional single-serving fruit cups produced by Dole Food Co., Westlake Village, Calif., and Del Monte Foods Co., Wilmington, Del.
Low Carb Strikes Again
One can't speak of the snack evolution without discussing low-carb diet mania. The low-carb diet has, to say the least, drawn attention to the overeating of "empty" calories. With that latest fad appearing to be going the way of all fads, its ultimate legacy â€" similar to the legacy of the no-fat craze a decade before — is that it encouraged consumers to pay closer attention to the quality of the calories they consume.
This nutrition-awareness spillover accounts for at least part of the resurgence we are seeing in different protein options. Dairy and nuts are beneficiaries of this. Whole grains have already begun to benefit from this, too, as consumers refocus their thinking about carbohydrates from (unhealthy) aversion to seeking carbohydrate sources that contribute significant nutrition benefits.
Packaging and promotion play a huge role in opening the snack realm to healthier options. Packaging is allowing more unique, individualized portions of different foods â€" something critical to supporting our grazing, eat-on-the-go culture. If chips and soda are the only things you can get in "to go" form, then these are the only products that will be eaten on the run.
Few will argue that sitting down and enjoying a meal slowly with friends and family isn't the better way to do it, but there is a lot of "do as I say, not as I do" in this approach. Improving the nutrition of the U.S. will not happen unless higher nutrition products are available to go.
Also, packaging solutions are crucial for the growth of healthier options in vending machines. A great example of this is Stonyfield Farms, Londonderry, N.H. Stonyfield Farms launched its "Menu for Change: Getting Healthy Foods into Schools" program in Rhode Island in 2003, and this program is growing rapidly.
This is a fairly complete program for improving the food schools offer to kids. The snack part of this program is a great example of making something work that too many say can't work. Stonyfield Farms provides vending machines and stocks them with products that must meet two criteria: they must be healthful, nutritious foods, and they must taste good. According to one Stonyfield spokesperson, "Our healthy vending machines demonstrate that if kids are offered healthy food that tastes good, they will eat it."
Dairy is a hit with kids via dozens of yogurt offerings, individual-serving combination cottage cheese and fruit packs and the wildly popular string cheese phenomenon. These would not have been traditionally defined as snacks in the days when salt and sugar ruled the category, but are fulfilling the true snack purpose as a quick small meal between meals. Whey and other dairy proteins are being used to increase the protein content of snacks while consequently replacing so-called "empty" carbohydrate calories with protein calories.
The definition of what constitutes a snack continues to grow with the more prominent role snacks are called upon to play in our upwardly/overly mobile society. At the same time, consumers are reaching for products not traditionally defined as snacks. The steady and continuing demise of the sit-down meal means snacks are becoming our meals.
One attempt to define the market segment of snack was "what is not eaten at the traditional breakfast, lunch or dinner." Today it seems more like "what is eaten instead of the traditional breakfast, lunch or dinner." If snacks are becoming our meals, at least it's a good thing they are becoming healthier and more nutritious.
About the Author
John K. Ashby is General Manager - Ingredients, for California Natural Products, a pioneering manufacturer of rice ingredients for the food industry, focuses on the Nutritional, Nutraceutical, Functional and the Organic Foods industries and serves on the Manufacturing, Processing, Packaging and Labeling committee of the Organic Trade Association.