2010 Readers' Choice Awards: Suppliers That Hit the Trifecta

Good price, good quality, good service: Here are the suppliers you say deliver it in 38 categories of ingredients, equipment and services.

By Dave Fusaro, Editor in Chief

Share Print Related RSS

"It's very competitive out there, but the suppliers with the trifecta of good price, good quality and good service quickly sort themselves to the top of our list."

Who can argue with that comment from Lissa McBurney of Boston's Dancing Deer Baking Company? And although McBurney is a specifier of ingredients, the same holds true for the buyers (and suppliers) of equipment and services in the food and beverage industry.

"With the ever increasing consumer awareness around food safety, equipment suppliers must continually improve the processes for maintenance and sanitation of their equipment," adds a plant ops executive from a Canadian meat processor. That's a good point for all equipment fabricators to remember.

Those comments typify the responses to our eighth annual Readers' Choice Awards survey. As we have in the past, we sent e-mail surveys to a subset of our circulation list between Thanksgiving of 2009 and New Year's. We got 227 responses back. This year, for the first time, we also took votes on our web site. After culling ineligible ballots, that added a few dozen more votes.

No supplier names were suggested; the form is an unaided recall survey. Voters represent all categories of the food and beverage industry. There are two separate surveys: one for our subscribers primarily involved in specifying processing and packaging equipment and a separate one for those buying ingredients and flavors. Also as usual, we got more votes in the ingredient categories than in the equipment and services ones. The winners in 11 categories of nutraceutical ingredients will be unveiled in the April issue in our Wellness Foods section.

Interestingly, very few of the comments made any mention of the tough times of the past year. As usual, the positive comments far out numbered the negative ones.

"Great ingredients are the first step to a great product," said a guy at a Pennsylvania cheese maker. "All the companies we use make great products."

"Overall I would say customer service is excellent," wrote a man at an East Coast company. "The industry as a whole suffered a black eye with the recent peanut salmonella issue in Georgia. We need to be able to rely on our suppliers to be truthful when they provide their [certificate of analysis] and other test data."

"We are very satisfied with the ability of our suppliers to provide pilot equipment/services to support technology evaluations and development," wrote a man at a canning company, who asked not to be identified. But elaborating over the phone, he said his favorite suppliers are those who agree to set up pilot equipment at the supplier's facility or loan or rent his company equipment to run under its own roof, so he can test new models or find process or energy efficiencies. "If the equipment works and they make it easy for us to scale up, those are the suppliers we eventually buy from," he added.

"Ninety percent of the companies we do business with understand the value of customer service and personal relationships. Their responsiveness, willingness to start small and build and their technical support keep us going back to them project after project," said a Florida maker of consumer baked goods toppings.

"All of the companies that I wrote in are outstanding in product, price and overall excellent customer service. I cannot say enough good things about them," said another.

"Most companies are very helpful. Our flavor, gum and starch companies are very helpful and prompt. They are always willing to give the extra push to make your project go through," wrote yet another.

"Food safety is so big – it's important to have a good supplier who understands that," commented an anonymous respondent.

Despite all those great compliments, there were some suggestions for improvement:

  • "Many suppliers are waiting for us (the customer) to call them, especially those on a preferred suppliers list," lamented one R&D guy.
  • "Always work with R&D to narrow choices (more focus) rather than overloading the R&D contact with samples," said a product developer at General Mills.
  • "We could always use more information on their products, especially on efficacy study/clinical study," said another R&D technician.
  • "Having replacement parts on hand is very important" to a guy at a ConAgra plant.
  • "[Service] is OK; I just wish the prices would come down a little," said a Colorado cheese cake maker.
  • At least one respondent was downright critical: "Customer service is down overall. It has been declining over the past 15 years that I have been doing the purchasing at my company," said an ingredient buyer at a sauces and dressings company.

But the overwhelming majority paint an encouraging picture of suppliers that are key components of the success of food & beverage companies. So we congratulate the 87 suppliers that were selecte. And we thank all the food and beverage processors who took the time to fill out this survey.

Turn to the next few pages to see who received the most votes for the 2010 Readers' Choice Awards.

Select a category:

{pb}

2010 Winners for Equipment Suppliers

Control Systems                                        
1. Rockwell 49%
2. Emerson Process Management 14%

Conveying Equipment
1. Hytrol 9%
2. Dorner 5%

Extruders
1. Wenger 18%

Flooring
1. Stonhard 12%

Flow Measurement
1. Emerson Process Management 20%
2. Endress+Hauser 17%

Form/Fill/Seal Equipment
1. Hayssen Sandiacre 10%
* Rovema 9%
* Triangle 8%

Heat Transfer Equipment
1. Alfa Laval 20%
APV/SPX Process 20%

Lubricants
1. Lubriplate 18%
2. Exxon/Mobil 15%
3. Petro Canada 12%

Metal Detection/X-ray/Inspection
1. Safeline/Mettler-Toledo 20%
2. Fortress 11%

Mixing & Blending
1. Lightnin/SPX Process 10%
* Munson 8%

Motors & Drives
1. Baldor 39%
2. Rockwell 15%
* SEW Eurodrive 13%

Packaging Materials
1. Cryovac/Sealed Air 12%
2. Tetra Pak 7%

Pest Management
1. Copesan 10%
Orkin 10%

Pumps
1. Waukesha Cherry Burrell/SPX 24%

Size Reduction
1. Urschel Laboratories 20%

Uniform Services
1. Aramark 26%
2. Cintas 5%

Weighing/Checkweighing
1. Mettler Toledo 24%

* Differences of less than 3% are considered a statistical tie

Move to:

{pb}

2010 Winners for Ingredient Suppliers

Beverage Flavors
1. Wild Flavors 25%
* Firmenich 24%
3. Givaudan 21%

Cheese & Cheese Ingredients
1. Kraft Food Ingredients 37%
2. Edlong Dairy Flavors 25%
3. Kerry 20%

Chocolate/Cocoa
1. Cargill 36%
2. ADM 32%
3. Barry Callebaut 23%

Colorants
1. Sensient 40%
2. Sethness 18%
3. GNT 13%
*Chr. Hansen 11%
*D.D. Williamson 11%

Dairy Flavors & Ingredients
1. Edlong Dairy Flavors 36%
2. Butter Buds 13%

Emulsifiers
1. Danisco 34%
2. Cargill 16%

Enzymes
1. Novozymes 26%
2. Danisco 16%
* Chr. Hansen 12%

Fats & Oils
1. ADM 27%
Bunge 27%
* Cargill 25%

Flavors-Savory
1. McCormick 19%
2. Kraft Food Ingredients 13%

Flavors-Sweet
1. Wild Flavors 7%
* Givaudan 6%
* IFF 5%

Fruits/Dried Fruits
1. Van Drunen Farms 16%

Grain Products
1. ConAgra Mills 34%
2. Cargill 30%
3. ADM 24%

Gums & Hydrocolloids
1. TIC Gums 50%
2. Gum Technology 10%
* CP Kelco 9%
* FMC 9%

Nuts
1. Golden Peanut/ADM 18%
2. Blue Diamond 15%

Salt
1. Cargill 49%
2. Morton 42%

Stabilizers
1. FMC 28%
2. Danisco 25%

Starches
1. National Starch 55%
2. Cargill 21%
3. Tate & Lyle 14%

Sugars
1. C&H/Domino/Florida Crystals 40%
2. Imperial Sugar 17%
3. Cargill 14%

Sweeteners (not sugar)
1. Tate & Lyle 22%
* ADM 20%
3. Cargill 16%

Vanilla
1. Virginia Dare 28%
2. David Michael 14%

Vegetables/Dried Vegetables
1. Van Drunen Farms 21%

* Differences of less than 3% are considered a statistical tie

Move to:

Share Print Reprints Permissions

What are your comments?

You cannot post comments until you have logged in. Login Here.

Comments

No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments