Voices: Editor's Plate

Editor's Plate: CSR Means Paying Taxes

Walgreen Co., increasingly a grocery retailer, is considering an offshore home to avoid U.S. corporate taxes.

By Dave Fusaro, Editor in Chief

“We live those values every day, as we try to reflect the vision of Charles R. Walgreen by doing what is fair and beneficial to others.”

I’m speaking of Walgreen Co., based here in the suburbs of my hometown Chicago. Walgreen’s in recent years has greatly increased the floor space it devotes to groceries, not just candy and gum, and it also has a burgeoning private label business. But if it moves a nominal head office to Switzerland, I won’t be buying my Maxwell House instant coffee and Splenda there anymore. And that truly is where I buy my coffee and sweetener and many other groceries for various reasons. Sorry, Kraft and McNeil/Tate and Lyle.

I suspect I won’t be alone. Stories in the Chicago media have created a backlash against this hometown favorite, which has been filling our prescriptions since 1901. This could alienate customers across the entire country, now that Walgreen’s has a national footprint (8,678 stores in all 50 states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands and Guam).

The company faces a tough choice, balancing profits against corporate social responsibility. One local news story likened this move to Walgreen’s renouncing its U.S. citizenship.

For background, Walgreen’s is in the process of acquiring the remaining 55 percent of Switzerland-based Alliance Boots, Europe’s largest pharmacy chain (it already owns 45 percent). That logical move comes with an interesting side benefit called a corporate tax inversion. By making itself in effect a subsidiary of a foreign parent, Walgreen’s can move its corporate home to low-tax Switzerland (or elsewhere in Europe). No additional bricks and mortar needed, and the well-paid execs of America’s pharmacy don’t need to buy chalets in the Alps or move there.

The only thing that changes is some paperwork.

This would save the firm millions, maybe hundreds of millions, in taxes … which presumably would be returned to shareholders in improved earnings. Except the biggest shareholders in Walgreen's are institutional investors and its own executives.

Referring back to the corporate social responsibility report: I couldn’t find one on Walgreen’s website, although they have a landing page devoted to five subtopics of that subject. Admirable stuff, like Community, Environmental Sustainability, Diversity, Supplier Diversity and Disability Inclusion. The quote at the top of this column comes from that page. Dodging taxes doesn’t sound compatible with those lofty goals.

I’m in dangerous territory here because I don’t know enough about taxes and international business dealings to make this a knockout punch. This is not a first for corporate America, although I think it is a first for a business that has this much reach into the food and beverage industry. And I always worry that the real culprits are investment firms and financial analysts, who may be unhappy with the share price – which looks pretty stellar to me.

Maybe Walgreen’s mere threat will motivate Congress to undertake a long-overdue examination of the corporate tax codes, closing some of the loopholes and maybe lowering some rates so that American firms can be profitable and competitive on a world scale. But that’s the thing: Nobody can call Walgreen’s noncompetitive. If it were, it wouldn’t be in a position to be buying Europe’s biggest pharmacy chain.

America has been good to Walgreen’s. Walgreen’s should return the favor.

More from this author...

Title

Editor's Plate: CSR Means Paying Taxes

Walgreen Co., increasingly a grocery retailer, is considering an offshore home to avoid U.S. corporate taxes.

07/21/2014

Editor's Plate: A Wild Ride Ahead

In a month of financial wrangling, a salute to the small food and beverage companies.

06/30/2014

Editor's Plate: Ridiculous Label Claims

Unsubstantiated or exaggerated claims have no place in this business.

05/14/2014

Editor's Plate: To GMO or not to GMO

Are consumers not interested or is it too soon to tell?

04/08/2014

Editor's Plate: If Nelson Peltz Ran PepsiCo

Due to a rift in the time-space continuum, we bring you this report from the March 2016 issue of Food Processing.

03/18/2014

Editor's Plate: The USA Could Use a Woman's Touch

Whether or not it’s the work of Indra Nooyi, PepsiCo’s generosity shows a heart and soul we all should emulate.

02/06/2014

Editors Plate: Welcome to 2014, the Year of …

We may be at the start of a brand new year, but 2014 appears to hold most of the same issues and concerns that 2013 held.

01/14/2014

Editor's Plate: My Second Visit to ConAgra

Twenty years after I first visited, this is a very different company.

12/13/2013

Editor's Plate: I Need an Incentive to Stay Put

The whole country needs to rethink the practice of competing for business by giving away taxpayer money, especially for existing jobs.

11/14/2013

Editor's Plate: The Real Cure for Obesity

You're the solution, not the problem.

10/29/2013

Editor's Plate: Tempest in a Yogurt Cup

Moldy yogurt recall teaches Chobani – and every food processor – several painful lessons.

09/19/2013

Editor's Plate: Another Reason To Hate Wall Street

Who's Nelson Peltz to tell PepsiCo how to run a food and beverage business?

08/15/2013

Editor's Plate: A Load of Benjamins ... and One Larry

...and an Irene, too. Even as the 'average' food industry salary breaks $100k, how does the CEO of Smithfield Foods warrant $12.9 million.

07/09/2013

Editor's Plate: Another American Processor Sells Out

I thought I was a free-marketeer, but this Smithfield deal bothers me.

06/17/2013

Editor's Plate: Swinging for the Fences

Three measures that new product development is alive and well.

05/14/2013

Editor's Plate: The Dangers of the Dangers of GMOs

It looks like marketing and profiteering are trumping science.

04/11/2013

Editor's Plate: I Worry for H.J. Heinz

Buffett's OK, but who's this profit-conscious Brazilian investment firm?

03/14/2013

Editor's Plate: New Year's Resolutions For Both of Us

Take this opportunity to set goals for the new year; I will.

01/14/2013

Editor's Plate: The Circle of Life Continues

Companies come and go in the food & beverage industry. Let's celebrate the up-and-comers.

12/13/2012

A More Important Vote in California

Proposition 37 looks likely to ignite the GMO debate nationally.

10/09/2012