Voices: Editor's Plate

Editor's Plate: CSR Means Paying Taxes

Walgreen Co., increasingly a grocery retailer, is considering an offshore home to avoid U.S. corporate taxes.

By Dave Fusaro, Editor in Chief

“We live those values every day, as we try to reflect the vision of Charles R. Walgreen by doing what is fair and beneficial to others.”

Two quick questions up front: 1. Do you have a corporate social responsibility (CSR) report? 2. Are you selling your groceries through a large retail chain that’s considering moving its corporate headquarters offshore just to dodge U.S. taxes?

I’m speaking of Walgreen Co., based here in the suburbs of my hometown Chicago. Walgreen’s in recent years has greatly increased the floor space it devotes to groceries, not just candy and gum, and it also has a burgeoning private label business. But if it moves a nominal head office to Switzerland, I won’t be buying my Maxwell House instant coffee and Splenda there anymore. And that truly is where I buy my coffee and sweetener and many other groceries for various reasons. Sorry, Kraft and McNeil/Tate and Lyle.

I suspect I won’t be alone. Stories in the Chicago media have created a backlash against this hometown favorite, which has been filling our prescriptions since 1901. This could alienate customers across the entire country, now that Walgreen’s has a national footprint (8,678 stores in all 50 states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands and Guam).

The company faces a tough choice, balancing profits against corporate social responsibility. One local news story likened this move to Walgreen’s renouncing its U.S. citizenship.

For background, Walgreen’s is in the process of acquiring the remaining 55 percent of Switzerland-based Alliance Boots, Europe’s largest pharmacy chain (it already owns 45 percent). That logical move comes with an interesting side benefit called a corporate tax inversion. By making itself in effect a subsidiary of a foreign parent, Walgreen’s can move its corporate home to low-tax Switzerland (or elsewhere in Europe). No additional bricks and mortar needed, and the well-paid execs of America’s pharmacy don’t need to buy chalets in the Alps or move there.

The only thing that changes is some paperwork.

This would save the firm millions, maybe hundreds of millions, in taxes … which presumably would be returned to shareholders in improved earnings. Except the biggest shareholders in Walgreen's are institutional investors and its own executives.

Referring back to the corporate social responsibility report: I couldn’t find one on Walgreen’s website, although they have a landing page devoted to five subtopics of that subject. Admirable stuff, like Community, Environmental Sustainability, Diversity, Supplier Diversity and Disability Inclusion. The quote at the top of this column comes from that page. Dodging taxes doesn’t sound compatible with those lofty goals.

I’m in dangerous territory here because I don’t know enough about taxes and international business dealings to make this a knockout punch. This is not a first for corporate America, although I think it is a first for a business that has this much reach into the food and beverage industry. And I always worry that the real culprits are investment firms and financial analysts, who may be unhappy with the share price – which looks pretty stellar to me.

Maybe Walgreen’s mere threat will motivate Congress to undertake a long-overdue examination of the corporate tax codes, closing some of the loopholes and maybe lowering some rates so that American firms can be profitable and competitive on a world scale. But that’s the thing: Nobody can call Walgreen’s noncompetitive. If it were, it wouldn’t be in a position to be buying Europe’s biggest pharmacy chain.

America has been good to Walgreen’s. Walgreen’s should return the favor.

More from this author...

Title

Reasons to be Optimistic About Food

I'm glad Sara Lee chose Hillshire Farm over Wonderbra.

03/01/2005

Keep in Control of the Supply Chain

If you're not managing your supply chain, it's probably managing you.

04/01/2005

Only You Can Make the Food Pyramid Work

Only General Mills has seized on the opportunity; other food companies must step up.

05/01/2005

Behavior Modification Presentation at Research Chefs Assn Conference

Tell consumers, ‘We care about your health.’ When people feel cared about, they become your most loyal customers.

06/01/2005

Food Processing's Deep Pool of Experts

We’ve created quite a deep pool of experts for both us and you to draw upon … in print and on the web.

07/01/2005

Tyson Foods Not Just a Chicken Company Anymore

Tyson Foods, no longer just a chicken company, is now the largest food processor in North America.

08/01/2005

Are You Doing Enough for Health?

As the recent IFT Show proved, there are plenty of healthful ingredient solutions out there.

09/01/2005

Donating Product to Second Harvest is a Win-Win

It’s a win-win-win. What better way to move unsalables, get a tax benefit and help hungry people?

10/01/2005

Gas Prices Change Eating Habits

If a lot of your eggs are in foodservice and fragmented retail formats, it’s time to reconsider the good old grocery store and people cooking at home.

11/01/2005

Why a Processor of the Year?

Are you finding ways to add value to your product? Have you wrung the inefficiencies out of your plants?

12/01/2005

Institute of Medicine Report Based on Outdated Research

The Institute of Medicine report on food advertising and childhood obesity is a serious indictment … based on outdated research.

01/01/2006

Is Biotechnology the Future of Food?

Why not a conference on biotechnology, but with the food industry calling the meeting to order?

02/01/2006

FDA Needs to Further Define Whole Grain Labeling

Editor in Chief Dave Fusaro urges food processors to tell the FDA to finish the job and define what are 'good' and 'excellent' sources of whole grains.

03/01/2006

What Does China's Emerging Superpower Status Mean for You?

China is a subject every businessman ought to get a handle on. So we at Food Processing have put together a webcast on the topic.

04/01/2006

Reser's Fine Foods Rises from Humble Beginnings

A lot of food companies started out dreaming big dreams based on a really good family recipe.

05/01/2006

Healthier Products Abound at 2006 FMI Show

The FMI show proved food processors are trying their best to formulate with the Dietary Guidelines in mind.

06/01/2006

American Medical Association's Uneducated Attitude on Salt

The AMA is battling salt. What if the organization got involved with something its members actually have proficient knowledge about? Say, infectious diseases?

07/01/2006

It's Okay to Leave in Calories and Fat

Ingredient solutions at the recent IFT show indicate it’s OK to leave in a few calories and some fat.

08/01/2006

Corn-Based Ethanol Raises Ingredient Prices

It’s amazing to see how $3-a-gallon gasoline finally has set off a frenzy to find alternatives to oil, not just here in the U.S. but around the world. Will we someday be competing with our own SUVs for food?

09/01/2006

Five Things to Know About PepsiCo CEO

With her personality, PepsiCo’s new CEO should shake up the whole food industry.

10/01/2006