Voices: Editor's Plate

Editor's Plate: To GMO or not to GMO

Are consumers not interested or is it too soon to tell?

By Dave Fusaro, Editor in Chief

It may be a difficult process, but everybody knows removing genetically engineered ingredients (GMOs) is what all consumers want and is the fast-track to soaring sales, right?

Not so fast.

We trumpeted "Cheerios Now GMO-Free" in a headline online in January and in our February print issue. Now, three months – admittedly only three months – into the new formulation for its iconic cereal, General Mills Inc. sees no pickup in sales and sounds like it's questioning the rationale behind this move.

In a phone interview in late March with the Associated Press, Chairman and CEO Kenneth Powell said the company has received good press, supportive letters and positive online comments for its decision -- but no incremental sales.

"It's what I expected," Powell told the AP. He said he was "not really seeing anything there that we can detect" in terms of a sales improvement. And the news organization paraphrased him as saying he believes genetically modified organisms aren't really a concern for most customers.

General Mills started shipping only its plain-formula Cheerios without GMOs in January. A spokesman explained the oats part was easy – he said there are no GMO oats in this country – but the company had to find non-GMO sources of corn starch and cane sugar.

Post Foods followed up with a Non-GMO Project-certified version of Grape-Nuts.

Regular Cheerios seemed like a logical product to try this out on, since its consumer base seems to be concerned mothers, especially ones feeding the cereal by hand to toddlers.

The other versions of Cheerios were unchanged. And from the very start, General Mills said it had no immediate plans to reformulate other cereals.

Big G used a low-key approach in the rollout, not really trumpeting the change – although it did get noticed by traditional and social media. AP said the reformulation came after a campaign by the group Green America, which prompted fans to express their support on the Cheerios' Facebook page.

After the change, Green America noted with some disdain General Mills did not obtain third-party verification, such as from the Non-GMO Project, for its claim.

So maybe General Mills did not give this marketing-inspired product change its all. Maybe the reformulation needed a little more time than just three months to be written off. The company could have, maybe should have, gotten official Non-GMO Project certification. It could have made a very big marketing splash over the change – which, however, would have cast doubts on the safety of its other cereals, which presumably have genetically engineered ingredients.

Nevertheless, the results are as unimpressive as they are inconclusive. Pretty much nothing has changed. Every food processor, those on either side of the GMO fence, still must weigh the logic of going GMO-free for their products, their markets, their consumers.

Capital spending way up

Another great feature of this month's issue is our annual Capital Spending Report. Capital expenditures are an interesting barometer of the health of the food and beverage industry, and it's encouraging to see our report this year predicting a 15 percent increase in the aggregate figure – at least for the 37 companies for which we have solid figures.

They may be only 37 companies, but they're 37 of the largest companies in the food & beverage industry. And collectively they account for $18.5 billion in capital spend.

The numbers are encouraging, and the hot product categories and other trends that are driving this investment should be noted by all food and beverage processors.

More from this author...

Title

Editor's Plate: Did Ben and Jerry Change the World?

Two tie-dyed hippies may have set the stage for today's corporate social responsibility efforts.

06/11/2012

Editor's Plate: Colorado's Cottage Foods Act

Is it an incubator for entrepreneurship or a recipe for disaster?

04/24/2012

Editor's Plate: All Things in Moderation

Create low- (but not no-) calorie beverages (and other food products) without fear of failing.

03/14/2012

Editor's Plate: We Both Had a Pretty Good Year

2011 was kind to the food & beverage industry and to us. Let's both keep that head of steam going into 2012.

01/10/2012

Editor's Plate: Heinz, Naturally

Another champion from Pittsburgh! 57 or so reasons why the not-just-ketchup company was a standout in 2011.

12/01/2011

Editor's Plate: Time to Remember Feeding America

Especially as the holidays approach; some of the benefits are yours.

11/14/2011

Editor's Plate: Where's the FDA's New Funding?

The Food Safety Modernizaton Act has become one of the victims of feuding in Washington. Is good enough good enough?

10/17/2011

Editor's Plate: The Triple Bottom Line

Should your CFO be your company’s sustainability watchdog?

09/23/2011

Editor's Plate: Salts Gets in Some Licks

But don't rush to judgment on either side of the sodium debate.

08/16/2011

Editor's Plate: Time to End the Ethanol Insanity

The food vs. fuel debate is tipping our way; don't let the momentum die.

07/21/2011

Editor's Plate: What Makes for a Great Trade Show?

Some are succeeding, some failing. You ought to go to New Orleans next month to make IFT Food Expo a success.

05/13/2011

Editor's Plate: People Have to Eat, Processors Ought To Build

Optimism runs rampant in our Annual Capital Spending Report.

04/12/2011

Editor's Plate: A Littler Joint Venture: Me & Goji

Alexander and Adam let you design your own cereal … and container.

03/14/2011

Editor's Plate: Some CEOs Come and Go, Some Don't

Hormel is a study in stability … and success.

02/22/2011

Editor's Plate: 2010 Was a Pretty Good Year

A toast to a surprisingly good 2010, with fingers crossed for 2011.

01/08/2011

Editor's Plate: Private Label vs. Brands

The rise of private label can only mean brands will raise their game.

12/13/2010

Editor's Plate: It's Been a Crazy 70 Years

For our anniversary, we take a fun look back at the recent history of food.

10/07/2010

Editor's Plate: Random Notes From China

On stevia, curing the world's ills and entering ‘the China century.'

08/27/2010

Editor's Plate: Kellogg Marketing Slammed Again

When the cereal company gets punched for how it markets to children, the whole food industry gets a black eye.

07/06/2010

Editor's Plate: More Signs the Recession Is Over

From our capital spending report to the new grocery stores in my neighborhood, food and beverage is leading the comeback.

04/08/2010