Voices: Nutrition Trends

Food Processors and Ingredient Suppliers Study School Lunch Programs for Innovative Ideas

Processors and ingredient suppliers need to collaborate in creating meals that are nutritious and desirable for this picky and often overweight demographic.

By Mark Anthony, Ph.D., Technical Editor

School lunch nutrition programs come in as many forms and approaches as there are school districts. But one constant is that budgets are always tight. However, processors who participate in the efforts to better feed our children can find satisfaction in not only doing the right thing but in creating products for a significantly large demographic. Case in point: The New York school system alone serves more than 1 million meals per day.

“Schools meals are expected to be universally acceptable to all students, so we have push back from both ends of the spectrum,” says Twyla Leigh, nutritionist for Collier County Public Schools in Naples, Fla. “They’re either ‘too healthy’ or not organic/vegan/scratch-cooking enough.”

Leigh admits school nutrition professionals realize that “one size does not fit all” and continue to seek out manufacturers of better tasting, healthy options, even as they are “challenged with labor issues, food safety concerns and balanced budgets.”

“School nutrition programs are expected to be self-supporting, paying for all food, labor, uniforms, equipment, water, electricity, gas, trash pick-up, payroll and human resource services.”

That according to Leigh and colleagues Terri Whitacre, director of school food and nutrition services for the Charlotte County Public School System in Punta Gorda, Fla., and Stacey Wykoski, foodservice director for the Jenison/Hudsonville School Food Service group in Jenison, Mich.

The three provide recommendations that manufacturers “should avoid MSG, high-fructose corn syrup, nitrates and items that are known to be issues in the food supply.” They also believe that GMOs are going to be a “big topic” moving forward. “Manufacturers also need to take the lead in better food labels: sugar listed on a label should refer to added sugars, not natural and added combined,” they note.

Food allergens also will become more challenging with the increase in children who have food intolerances or allergies, says Leigh. “Gluten and peanuts are big issues with school-age children. Being involved with national ingredient and food label access, even with scanners and a more usable way to obtain this information, to link it to the school menus would be a huge victory for manufacturers, school nutrition and the children.”

Waste not

There are huge challenges facing any program designed to feed wholesome, desirable meals five days per week to hundreds of kids at a time in three or more 30 minute blocs around the noon hour. The biggest, perhaps, is an endless schoolyard tug-of-war between the cost of production and the staggering cost of plate waste.

In a study titled “School Lunch Waste Among Middle School Students: Nutrients Consumed and Costs,” by Juliana Cohen et alia, and published last year in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, the authors write critically, “The National School Lunch Program has been guided by modest nutrient standards, and the palatability of meals, which drives consumption, receives inadequate attention. School food waste can have important nutritional and cost implications for policymakers, students and their families.”

The study measured plate waste in four Boston area schools, two under intervention via the Chef Initiative -- in which a professional chef trained cafeteria staff to make healthier school meals -- and two control. The methods described that “costs associated with food waste were calculated and the percentage of foods consumed was compared with a gold standard of 85 percent consumption.”

Results of the study showed, “Overall, students consumed less than the required/recommended levels of nutrients. An estimated $432,349 of food — 26.1 percent of the total food budget — was discarded” and “for most meal components, substantially less than 85 percent was consumed.”

There was good news. According to lead researcher Cohen, new USDA standards (see “Back to School,” below) were helping to improve kids’ diets in the schools investigated.

Research teams visited each school twice before the changes, in fall 2011, and twice after the changes, in fall 2012. More students were taking and eating fruits and vegetables, with overall consumption of those foods rising.

Still, the study’s authors concluded that there was “substantial food waste” among the Boston students and that “overall, students' nutrient consumption levels were below school meal standards, and foods served were not valid proxies for foods consumed.” They found that costs associated with discarded foods, if translated nationally for school lunches, would equal more than $1.25 billion in waste annually. “Students might benefit if additional focus were given to the quality and palatability of school meals,” they added.

Opportunity knocks

While waste, of course, is a bad thing, within these statistics some see possibilities.

“So far, I think schools and the food industry have done a great job of implementing a challenging new set of standards on a pretty tight turnaround, bringing in more fruits and vegetables, adding whole grains, reducing sugar and sodium,” says Laura Daly, childhood nutrition marketing leader for Cargill Inc., Wayzata, Minn. “Ingredient companies and manufacturers have the opportunity to collaborate to take school meals to the next level.”

Daly sees the primary objectives for enhancing school lunch programs as focusing on taste, texture and visual improvements. The idea is to design foods just for kids. “For children, taste is king. A lot is being written about wasted food, food ending up in cafeteria garbage cans [sometimes] as a result of the new nutritional standards. But at the root of this is an opportunity to enhance the appeal of these foods for kids — from a taste, texture or visual perspective, or all three.

“We know it takes time for children to adapt to new flavors and textures,” Daly continues. “As an industry, we collectively still have some work to do to remove the developing stigma that, for example, whole-grain breads and pastas do not taste good. A great way this can be done is by formulating with ingredients such as white spring whole wheat flour, or MaizeWise whole grain corn flour.” (Cargill makes WheatSelect white whole wheat and MaizeWise whole grain corn flours.)

“Through using these sorts of ‘stealth health’ solutions in formulations, our customers can deliver bakery products that are winners with kids and contribute to meeting the increased whole grain requirements,” Daly says.

Recognizing that it can pose a challenge for school foodservice directors to attain nutrition profiles that comply with standards while controlling costs, Daly invites a closer look at an old standby in doing both: soy. “For companies searching for ways to cost-effectively compete in the new school lunch market with meat products, textured soy protein is one way to do it,” she states. “Versatile and packed with protein, soy can make meat go further and meet school lunch program credit requirements."

Daly describes how Cargill combined its Prosante brand textured soy flour and Prolia brand defatted soy flour with beef in a mini-beef patty on a whole-grain bun prototype. “The soy flours are 50 percent protein, and Prosante improves the texture of lean meat products,” Daly says. “In a kid-friendly size and with a juicy texture, it's easy to forget these 2-oz. cooked patties are reduced in fat to 5g per serving, compared to 10g in a traditional 2-oz. hamburger.”

The buns used contained 7g of whole grain per 28g bun and used MaizeWise 100 percent whole-grain corn with WheatSelect 100 percent white whole-wheat flour.

No canned response

Interestingly, nearly all the experts at the heart of the processed food industry stressed fresh foods at every opportunity.

“Schoolyard gardens can offer healthy, cost-reduced or free foods to the schools, to the children, teachers and administrators,” suggests Jeffrey Lind, vice-president of the health business unit at Frutarom Inc., North Bergen, N.J. He points to famed chef Alice Waters Berkeley's “Edible Schoolyard Program,” a national program that demonstrates the feasibility of such gardens.

Also key is understanding that, while more practical than many operators of school foodservice systems are aware of, there still are current limitations to such a sometimes idealistic approach. “Limited budgets might just be the greatest weakness in creating healthier school lunches, although it’s going to vary at different schools,” states Lind. “Access and ability to pay for top quality ingredients is key, too.”

Because of this, processors and ingredient makers also recognize they play significant roles in the creation of healthier school lunch menus. The goal of helping to create menus that enhance general health and that can hopefully counter the present epidemic of obesity comes from these experts’ unique perspective on how to improve school lunch foods within the parameters of processed food products.

It’s not surprising that a number of processors getting involved in helping influence the development and production of foods for such a picky and often grudging audience do so as a personal mission.

“I have four kids and I see the school lunch menus — they’re nutritionally horrible,” exclaims Domonic Biggi, CEO of Beaverton Foods Inc., Hillsboro, Ore. The company, a multigenerational, family-owned manufacturer of gourmet and private label foods and condiments, understands the position condiments play in making foods better.

No illusions exist for Biggi that condiments can replace whole foods. Listing the primary objectives for enhancing school lunch programs, Biggi notes a need to “eliminate all the bad choices” offered to school kids. “The childhood obesity rates are horrible; how can you afford not too?” Biggi questions. “If you give kids a choice between a hamburger and a salad, they are going to select the hamburger. Don’t give kids the option to make a bad choice.”

Biggi sees the persistence of deep-fried foods as another significant problem. “Schools need to get away from cheaply processed foods and buy more local or whole foods, and [see] that they are sautéed or otherwise better prepared.” He says that, to immediately improve school lunch nutrition, “food manufacturers can use cleaner ingredients” and make their products more wholesome.

“However,” he adds, “I put the onus on the school districts to purchase higher quality products. I challenge the school districts to spend an extra penny toward quality products — or continue to watch kids’ obesity rates increase.” He also advocates more teaching of nutrition in schools in order to help kids make the right nutrition choices.

What’s inside

One easy and immediate step to improve school lunch nutrition could be adding functionality to beverages. “That would be a good way to transition to improved school lunch nutrition [because] dairy in many forms is also a familiar food to children worldwide," says Frutarom’s Lind. "Single-serving units can ensure that omegas and minerals, such as iron, for example in the form of AB-Fortis [Frutarom’s microencapsulated iron ingredient] are dosaged and consumed properly.”

Lind points out dairy is a healthful mixture in its own right, and it can be a good carrier for other nutrients. Flavored milk, while controversial, has been shown to increase nutrient intake in children who otherwise would opt for unhealthy alternatives. “Chocolate in the form of milk, in a bar or as pudding is always an appealing, desirable flavor and it happens to mask off notes [of added vitamins and minerals] competently,” he continues. “Between these food choices there are several directions to take.”

As a way of closing the gap between what children have come to expect from school lunches and what is in the best interest of their health, Lind suggests a number of acceptable ways to encourage healthy eating in children.

“Familiar foods or familiar forms are the best to start with and can be a key point to get children on board without creating a gap in the first place,” he says. “Frozen yogurt instead of ice cream is one example. Vegetable purees can accommodate a range of nutritious, functional ingredients and can be easily incorporated into many different types of foods – everything from smoothies to pizza sauce and both savory and sweet.”

Lind also suggests squash formulations as nutritious functional ingredient carriers that “can go both ways, sweet or savory.” He also acknowledges that sweet treats can “secretly” incorporate nutritious ingredients and/or functionality. “I’ve seen brownie recipes made with black beans that give the brownie a chewy, delicious texture with no hint of the source material.”

Ingredient suppliers are uniquely positioned to help, with comprehensive ingredient solutions, systems, premixes and ingredient portfolios, plus the facilities to aid processors in product development and problem solving. Whether a need to utilize whole grains, fibers and proteins or reduce or replace sugar, sodium or fat, suppliers are valuable team members in the effort to make lunchtime a better, healthier time for school kids.

“We can take a holistic approach to reformulating for more nutrient density,” says Cargill’s Daly. “By utilizing capabilities in food applications and sensory testing and combining them with a deep understanding of ingredient functionality, we can deliver an end product children will enjoy eating. This also helps our customers get to market more quickly with successful product innovations and reformulations.”

As Daly confesses, “We’re making good progress, but the work is just beginning for all the stakeholders — USDA, schools, food manufacturers and ingredients suppliers — to work together to make school lunches healthier and to provide food kids look forward to eating each day.”

More from this author...


Expanding the Definition of Snacks

We once could have defined the four basic food groups of the snack universe as"sugar, salt, fat and fast." That definition is expanding while the boundaries are disappearing.


Food Bars Ideal for On-The-Go Consumers

Breakfast/cereal/snack bars are ideal for on-the-go consumers; and they can mesh well with the new Dietary Guidelines.


Functional Beverage Market Grows Aggressively

Because of the convenience and pleasure they offer, functional beverages are one of the most aggressive growth segments in the health and wellness foods arena.


Low-Carb Diets and Bone Health

Mark Anthony, Ph.D., joins the Wellness Foods family as a contributing editor with the monthly column, "Nutrition Beyond the Trends." This month: the relationship between protein consumption and bone health.


Glycemic Index is Not for Everyone

This month, Dr. Mark Anthony warns us of a new twist on the old low-carb nutrition fad. Handy as it is for diabetics, the Glycemic Index isn't the "be-all and end-all" of carbohydrate nutrition for everyone.


Thai Food Grows in Popularity

What is there to not attract people to Thai? The typical Thai dish balances all flavor elements; sweet, astringent, salty, piquant, tart and uomi (meaty); with a surprising lightness and delicacy that makes for a whole greater than the sum of its parts.


Co-Q10 Update from Leading Co-Q10 Research Lab

Co-Q10 has been lauded for its antioxidant properties and its role in energy production. Contributing Editor Dr. Mark Anthony previously managed one of the nation's leading Co-Q 10 research labs; here he brings his expertise to bear on an update of this vital nutrient.


Boron Builds Bone Health

In the not too distant future, nutrition experts may tell us to include boron-rich foods in our diet. This largely ignored element is being studied more intently at present, as it seems to play a key role in coordinating other nutrients involved in bone health.


Nutrition Trends: Don't Fear Tropical Oils

Dr. Mark Anthony puts tropical oils in their proper nutritional perspective.


Ready-To-Cook Combines Convenience and Quality

Convenience and quality make ready-to-cook the next likely culinary craze for the time-starved consumer.


Cleansing Diets Explained

Dr. Mark Anthony discusses so-called "cleansing" diets and the making of this common part of dietary balance into an exploitable mystery.


The Promise of Conjugated Linoleic Acid

The fats we find on the dinner table today aren’t quite the same as the ones our great-grandparents ate. Conjugated linoleic acid is one fatty acid we would do well to become reacquainted with.


Raw Diet Nutritionally Overrated

Dr. Mark Anthony explains that those who suggest we should eat "all raw, all the time" are offering us a raw deal, nutritionally speaking.


Vitamin D Deficiency Makes a Comeback

Vitamin D deficiency, thought to be a thing of the past, is coming back.


Multipurpose Taurine Works Alone

The powerful amino acid taurine doesn’t hang around building proteins.


2006 Flavor Trends Forecast

Here, too, health exerts its influence: How about spices that fight cancer, chocolate for heart-health and sweet-hot combos that improve satiety?


Probiotics Popular in Functional Foods

Probiotics are the new rage in functional foods.


Is Hoodia Cactus Really a Miracle Ingredient?

Is the South African cactus really a weight-loss miracle ingredient, or just another (expensive) nutrition fad?


Potatoes Villainized by Questionable Science

Questionable conclusions and reckless reporting have painted potatoes as dietary 'bad guys.' Dr. Anthony begs to differ.


Tart Cherries Contain Potent Antioxidants

Tart cherries as the latest in health foods may sound like little more than sour grapes. But there's nothing sour about their positive effect on health. Centuries of folklore about the health powers in these little jewels are finding support in research. Tart cherries, those we use in cherry pie, may be among the most potent of nature’s anti-inflammatory foods.