Voices: Well Noted

In Praise of Smoothies

Wellness Foods Editor David Feder, R.D., tells tales out of school and the merging of smoothies with meal replacement beverages.

By David Feder, R.D., Editor

I’m a smoothie lover. Any time of year, fruit, juice, yogurt and a dab of peanut butter or a scoop of soy protein powder makes up my idea of a smoothie. When I was earning my RD (registered dietitian) I was a bit of a plague on my professors. I came into the program following a 15-year career as a professional chef and restaurateur. I was also older than most of the others in the class by more than a decade (not to mention the same age as two of the profs). In a nutshell, I was fairly set in my ways about what could and could not be done when it comes to feeding people.

I also had the drive of someone who entered a new career choice from the, “If you don’t like how something is done, don’t complain, do something!” point of view. Seven years earlier I had extensive abdominal surgery. I was recovering flat on my back and NPO (nil per os, meaning “nothing by mouth”) for 29 days. I wasn’t even permitted to suck on ice chips.

By the time they disconnected the tubes and told me I could eat again I’d shed nearly a quarter of my body weight. The hospital dietitian asked me a million questions and developed a diet for me. Yet when they started to bring me food, it was so unutterably awful I could not eat it.

Imagine: No food for a month yet when finally available, the food was so off-putting I left it untouched. Actually, I covered it up so as not to even have to look at it.

On her daily visits, the dietitian begged me to eat, asking what she could bring. I kept requesting fresh, wholesome foods — smoothies, steamed veggies and stir-fries, salads with real lettuce and greens. I kept getting gray, overcooked canned green beans with slimy chunks of pork fat and hockey-puck slabs of rubber “meat” (even with my chart clearly marked “Kosher vegetarian”), sawdust-textured powdered potatoes and World War II-surplus desserts.

Had it not been for my family and friends smuggling fresh fruits, vegetables, nourishing soups and Chinese food (against strict hospital policy), I could have starved to death. So I decided to become a dietitian.

This preset notion brought me to the brink of my dietetics instructors’ forbearance, because when we had to make up menu plans, I invariably created menus based around foods people could eat and should eat when they are recovering from serious diseases or trauma. I always kept within the assigned parameters of menu planning as it involves pricing, special needs, availability and equipment.

Nevertheless, I caught flak because my menus were unconventional, involving (of course) smoothies, steamed veggie stir-fries and salads with real lettuce and greens, among other things.

The smoothies really set one prof’s teeth on edge (a wonderful, wonderful teacher by the way, as well as a truly delightful person who makes a killer mango salad herself — none of our disagreements was ever personal). She kept insisting it was unrealistic and impossible to give patients smoothies. It got to the point where she would dock points on assignments and exams if I included smoothies and I would go right on doing it. It may “never have been done before” but, for the spots where I prescribed them, smoothies were the right thing.

Today, the consumer demand for nutrition-oriented foods that are as delicious as they are restorative have influenced meal replacement products. There’s an unparalleled line of beverages blurring the line between smoothies and those liquid meal replacements for the unwell. Take the Novartis International AG (Basel, Switzerland) line of Boost beverages. They include Strawberry Sensation Smoothie, Peach Perfection Smoothie, Banana Blender, Blueberry Blaster and Strawberry-Banana Smoothie.

And smoothies themselves are everywhere. Shelf spaces in stores are filling up with brands large and small, familiar and new. You can grab a smoothie at small kiosks in many cities, and larger purveyors such as the Jamba Juice Co. chain (San Francisco) are dotting the countryside. Even vending machines stock them.

I wonder if, when my professor sees products such as those on the menu plans of a student or looks around her class and sees healthy students sipping the same prepared smoothies, she remembers me and my one-man smoothie campaign.

Note: I want to thank all my instructors at the University of Texas department of nutrition. They are an incredibly gifted group and inspired me greatly, even when I knew I was driving them crazy.

More from this author...


In Praise of Smoothies

Wellness Foods Editor David Feder, R.D., tells tales out of school and the merging of smoothies with meal replacement beverages.


What Makes a Snack Good or Bad?

Editor David Feder, R.D., wrestles with the question of what makes a snack -- and snacking in general -- "good" or "bad."


The Trouble with E-Newsletters

Wellness Foods exists to be of service to our readers. The same holds true for the Food Processing website and our e-newsletters. But is that message getting through? Editor David Feder tells why he sometimes feels like Rodney Dangerfield.


Beware of Nutrition Misinformation

Everybody's an expert -- or so they seem to think -- when it comes to nutrition. This myopic egotism opens the door to misinformation and a swarm of nutrition fads and crazes, says Editor David Feder.


Processors Work to Ease Diabetes Compliance

Editor David Feder discusses how processors are working hard to make compliance easier for persons with diabetes.


Has Nutrition Reporting Turned a Corner?

Editor David Feder, R.D., wonders if the tide is finally turning against slipshod reporting of nutrition science.


Flavor is the Name of the Product Development Game

Editor David Feder reminds us flavor is the name of the game.


Report from 2005 IFT Expo

This year's IFT show served up a plethora of new and wondrous ingredients, the wisdom of Malcolm Gladwell, and the announcement of the World Food Prize.


Glycemic Index Often Misused

The phrase "glycemic index" - GI - is being tossed about a lot in wellness foods circle lately. We heard a lot about the glycemic index within the patois of the low-carb diet craze. Most of what was said and written about GI was in the form of misguided, misunderstood or deliberately misdirected information.


2005 Natural Products Expo East Report

If it had a health component and could be eaten, imbibed, swallowed, lathered on, rubbed in or even worn, it was on the show floor at the Natural Products Expo East.


ADA Conference Explores Nutrition Topics

The DNA of diet and other new trends from the American Dietetic Association conference.


Kosherfest 2005 Exhibits Merging Trends

Kosherfest 2005 showed that the merger of the food industry's two hottest trends is no mixed marriage.


Food Industry New Year's Resolutions for 2006

What resolutions have you made for processing in 2006? Editor David Feder has a few suggestions.


Communicating Whole Grain Needs to Consumers

How can food and nutrition professionals best communicate to consumers advice on how to boost their intake of whole grains?


Well Noted: Tell Me What to Eat

Where nutrition educators are struggling, manufacturers may be succeeding.


More Ammo Brought into Fight Against Diabetes

Diabetes afflicts an ever-growing percentage of the population. However, creators and manufacturers of foods designed either directly or indirectly to prevent the development of obesity and diabetes, are bringing more and more ammo to the battle every year.


Science Degrees Can Be Used to Mislead

"Vitamin E is harmful", "salt is poison", "organic cookies decimate the endangered orangutan habitat" and "the childhood obesity crisis is a red herring made up by the liberal media." These assertions are just a sampling of the flagrant misuses of science degrees by people who should know better. When it’s expert versus expert, everyone gets short-changed.


Organic Foods are Where Innovation and Sales Growth Meet

A visit to the "Power of Five" conglomeration of food shows in Chicago last month left the distinct impression that organic foods "are where it's at" in terms of innovation and sales growth.


Survey Says Nearly Half of Consumers Don't Count Calories

If a calorie is consumed in the forest and no one is there to count it, will it still show up on your waistline? We analyze the IFIC Food and Health Survey’s disturbing finding that 43 percent of consumers refuse to even think about keeping track of their caloric intake.


Media Reaction to Soy Overstates Risks

Soy recently got its turn under the hot lamp of media accusation for crimes committed in the name of health. Research purportedly linking soy to cancer has been splattering the pages of popular media with its tofu gore. As always, the truth is more benign – pun intended – than the columnists would have us believe.