Voices: Well Noted

What Makes a Snack Good or Bad?

Editor David Feder, R.D., wrestles with the question of what makes a snack -- and snacking in general -- "good" or "bad."

By David Feder, R.D., Editor

I practically live on snacks; that is, I graze throughout the day. This is hardly uncommon, as is borne out by the multibillion-dollar snack food industry. But for those of us who grew up in the 1960s, there was a stigma attached to the word “snack” that’s hard to shake. We were told by experts (Mom, teachers and the family doctor), not to eat between meals, to “avoid snacks,” to “not fill up on junk” and other such caveats.

By the time I was studying nutrition and dietetics, the drift went the other way. Health experts were recommending dividing calories across six small daily meals as a way to maintain level blood sugar and avoid obesity.

What changed? It wasn’t the nutrition knowledge. Although the science has seen an extraordinary quantity of growth and change in the past decades, snack foods loaded with sugar or salt were never associated with health and fitness. The pivotal change was to snacks themselves. They just plain got healthier. Yes, we Americans still love our sugary candy and our salty potato chips — they continue to rack up billions in sales per year — but granola bars and trail mix and soy nuts are also mega sellers.

And even within the so-called “junk” snack categories, manufacturers are making efforts to let us have our chips and eat them too. It’s getting harder and harder to find a cracker or a chip that doesn’t proudly proclaim itself free of trans-fatty acids, implicated in heart disease.

Other crispy favorites are “baked, not fried” to reduce the overall saturated fat content. Vitamins and minerals are added, sugar is taken out and those classic standards of health, fruit and vegetables, are given unprecedented attention in the food business, whether as ingredients within a snack food or in unique preparation or packaging to encourage their being snapped off the shelf.

These changes are happening across the spectrum of packaged foods. It was once the mission of niche marketers to provide healthier “alternatives” to mainstream snacks. But recently two of the biggest manufacturers of snack foods, Frito-Lay and Kraft, made across-the-board changes, taking giant, proactive steps toward “unjunking” junk food.

So put this in your back pocket: There’s nothing wrong with noshing on a healthy snack (or even the occasional “empty” calorie). Better you should eat when you’re hungry so that you don’t overeat when you’re not.

Eat Well!

Note: As we go to press, the USDA releases the 2005 Dietary Guidelines for Healthy Americans. To find out what’s changed and what the experts have to say about the guidelines, see “New Dietary Guidelines Released.”

More from this author...


What Makes a Snack Good or Bad?

Editor David Feder, R.D., wrestles with the question of what makes a snack -- and snacking in general -- "good" or "bad."


Well Noted: Tell Me What to Eat

Where nutrition educators are struggling, manufacturers may be succeeding.


Well Noted: Moving Up and Southern Hospitality


Well Noted: Judging Health Food by Its Cover

Making a case for more aggressive pursuit of sustainable packaging now that bioplastics have caught up to demand.


Well Noted: A Wellness New Year

Editor David Feder’s shamelessly subjective ramblings on some of the good, the bad and the weird of last year’s wellness products and stories. Plus: Changes to the magazine for 2007.


Well Noted: 2007 Annual Meat Conference

The 2007 Annual Meat Conference, sponsored by the American Meat Institute and the Food Marketing Institute includes new session on kosher- and halal-certification megatrends.


Trends from the Natural Products Expo East

The Natural Products Expo East, held last month in Baltimore, showcased thousands of new products for health and wellness as usual. But there were also some interesting trends worth taking note of. Sustainable and Free-Trade are making aggressive inroads, cherries are back, and editor David Feder admits he was wrong about the popularity of açai.


The Trouble with E-Newsletters

Wellness Foods exists to be of service to our readers. The same holds true for the Food Processing website and our e-newsletters. But is that message getting through? Editor David Feder tells why he sometimes feels like Rodney Dangerfield.


The Four Bs of Nutraceuticals

Those of us seeking to add wellness ingredients to our diets have a wealth of choices. Until we get to the actual products, where it seems, with few exceptions, we're restricted to beverages, bars, baked goods and breakfast foods. We need to look at other opportunities processors have to incorporate functional ingredients into the food chain.


Survey Says Nearly Half of Consumers Don't Count Calories

If a calorie is consumed in the forest and no one is there to count it, will it still show up on your waistline? We analyze the IFIC Food and Health Survey’s disturbing finding that 43 percent of consumers refuse to even think about keeping track of their caloric intake.


Science Degrees Can Be Used to Mislead

"Vitamin E is harmful", "salt is poison", "organic cookies decimate the endangered orangutan habitat" and "the childhood obesity crisis is a red herring made up by the liberal media." These assertions are just a sampling of the flagrant misuses of science degrees by people who should know better. When it’s expert versus expert, everyone gets short-changed.


Report from 2005 IFT Expo

This year's IFT show served up a plethora of new and wondrous ingredients, the wisdom of Malcolm Gladwell, and the announcement of the World Food Prize.


Processors Work to Ease Diabetes Compliance

Editor David Feder discusses how processors are working hard to make compliance easier for persons with diabetes.


Organic and Healthy Losing Meaning Through Overuse

Do the terms "organic" and "healthy" lose their meaning when they're applied to every food and beverage product? There’s danger in blurring lines between what is organic or healthy and what is merely marketed as such.


Organic Foods are Where Innovation and Sales Growth Meet

A visit to the "Power of Five" conglomeration of food shows in Chicago last month left the distinct impression that organic foods "are where it's at" in terms of innovation and sales growth.


Organic By Any Other Name

The boom in demand for organic foods and ingredients threatens to outpace supply. Yet some companies are coming under fire for allegedly “fudging” what is truly organic. The question is, do the cows have to be happy for the milk to be organic?


New Product and Ingredient Trends from 2007 National Products Expo West

A report on new product and ingredient trends from the 2007 Natural Products Expo West / Supply Expo show in Anaheim, Calif.


More Ammo Brought into Fight Against Diabetes

Diabetes afflicts an ever-growing percentage of the population. However, creators and manufacturers of foods designed either directly or indirectly to prevent the development of obesity and diabetes, are bringing more and more ammo to the battle every year.


Media Reaction to Soy Overstates Risks

Soy recently got its turn under the hot lamp of media accusation for crimes committed in the name of health. Research purportedly linking soy to cancer has been splattering the pages of popular media with its tofu gore. As always, the truth is more benign – pun intended – than the columnists would have us believe.


Kosherfest 2005 Exhibits Merging Trends

Kosherfest 2005 showed that the merger of the food industry's two hottest trends is no mixed marriage.