Different Mixers for Different Food Blending Applications

Mixing and blending are fundamental to many food processes, and matching the machine to the application is the first step in ensuring consistent results and quality outcomes.

By Kevin T. Higgins, Managing Editor

1 of 2 < 1 | 2 View on one page

The ideal mixing or blending machine may well exist for your food product; the challenge is identifying which one is perfect for your specific application.

The advent of the high-shear pump obliterated the line between mixing and pumping; it also scrambled the meaning of shear. No matter: There are so many other factors in liquid/powder, liquid/liquid and liquid/air blending that no single  mixer could possibly satisfy all the general requirements, let alone the specific needs of a manufacturer.

One attribute that all processors expect, however, is a cleanable, sanitary machine. Marine propellers continue to be used by some firms, but that method's days are numbered. While they wouldn't pass a rigorous food safety audit, marine propellers do meet many processing requirements. Silverson Machines Inc. sought to meet this need with a sanitary unit seven years ago when it introduced Ultramix, an in-tank mixer that delivers a degree of high shear without turning solids into purees.

"We found there was a gap in the market," explains Matt Smith, sales director at U.K.-based Silverson, with U.S. operations based in East Longmeadow, Mass.

"At the bottom you have a marine propeller agitator, and at the top is our high-shear mixer. With Ultramix, we came in the middle."

Smith would get an argument from other suppliers about the top end's gold standard, but his point about the middle market is valid. Heat-and-eat meals are very popular in Western Europe and a growing category in North America, and consumers expect fresh ingredients that resemble their original form more than they do strained baby food. "You don't want to put too much energy in and change the rheology of the product," points out Smith. A propeller will satisfy that requirement, but its nooks and crannies would make a microbiologist cringe.

Silverson preempts the harborage issue by machining the head of the Ultramix from a "solid billet of stainless steel," he explains. No welds, sanitary or otherwise, are involved, and a compressed O-ring isolates the threads on the shaft, preventing any contact with the product.

The unit can be characterized as a mobile rotor/stator mixer, a class of machines that provides maximum flexibility for small-batch blending. Manufacturers typically mount the unit on a movable stand and insert the shaft into the vessel of their choosing. Tote bins containing up to 1,800 gallons and other difficult geometries can be thoroughly blended and mixed.

Another portable solution is the Conti-TDS, which also works on the rotor/stator principle and excels in wetting and dispersing fast-swelling powders into liquids. Positioned outside a process tank, the unit draws in the solid and liquid from opposite sides into the dispersion zone, pulling the powder in under vacuum and effectively blending it before agglomerations such as fish eyes can form.

Blending of gums is a common application, according to Rick Isherwood, president of Powder Technologies Inc., Hainesport, N.J., the technology's North American distributor. "Gums are one of the most challenging of the fast-swelling products but one of the easiest for us," Isherwood maintains. His mixer can handle a wide range of viscosities, from low viscous up to 250,000 centipoise. PTI's Ystral unit recently received 3-A certification and can be used in CIP processes.

Developed in Germany, Conti-TDS (shorthand for transport and dispersing system) received U.S. patent protection in 1996. "A lot of copycats have tried to duplicate it, but the patents are so strong, they have been unable," says Isherwood.

Two-stream progression

Leading processors of carbonated beverages began the transition from static mixers and multiple tanks for blending more than 20 years ago, and mid-sized manufacturers of all types of beverages are beginning to follow. High ingredient costs and multiple changeovers daily are key drivers, but human psychology also plays a role: Scrapping a process that works requires a leap of faith in newer technology. After decades of tire kicking, food company managers are beginning to make a change.

Among the firms helping them with the transition is TechniBlend Inc. in Waukesha, Wis. Heavily populated by process engineers and KHS alumni, TechniBlend integrates Coriolis mass flow meters, instrumentation and components from multiple vendors with its TB-200 blender, an in-line unit that precisely mixes two ingredients before passing the fluid on to the next blender, until the formula is satisfied.

The system is a variation of process analytic technology (PAT), the approach favored by FDA for pharmaceutical manufacturing. PAT uses real-time feedback from sensors to ensure that out-of-spec product is not released to downstream value-added processes, thereby improving finished goods outcomes and slashing in-process waste.

1 of 2 < 1 | 2 View on one page
Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.


No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments